Obese Kidney Cancer Patients Survive Longer Compared to Normal BMI Patients

Obese patients with kidney cancer had better survival rates than patients with a low or normal BMI, even though obesity is a risk factor for kidney cancer.

Highlights

Obesity, in spite of being a risk factor, is associated with better survival rates in kidney (renal) cancer than a low or normal Body Mass Index (BMI)
There was a slower disease progression in obese patients.
Pathological characteristics of the tumor growth were less dangerous in obese patients
Obese patients responded better to targeted therapies and had better survival even with advanced disease.

Contradicting Role of Obesity in Kidney Cancer

Obesity has always been associated with increased risk of development of cancer including kidney cancer. It has also been associated with poorer outcomes in patients with the disease.

Renal Cell Carcinoma-Causes-Risk Factors-Symptoms-Diagnosis-Treatment-Prevention
Renal cell carcinoma is kidney cancer that affects the lining of the kidney tubules. The initial stages of the cancer are asymptomatic and this makes early management of the disease difficult.

‘The obesity paradox - risk factor as well as good prognostic indicator in kidney cancer.’

However, researchers led by scientists at Dana-Farber Cancer Institute have performed a study showing better survival rates in obese patients with kidney cancer compared to normal or low Body Mass Index (BMI) patients.

This study, involving thousands of patients in four databases, has been published in the Journal of Clinical Oncology . Surprisingly, it showed that obese or overweight patients, especially those suffering from advanced or metastatic kidney cancer had slower rate of progression of the disease and better survival rates.

Results of the Dana Farber Study

Mantra to Prevent Childhood Obesity � Vigorous Physical Activity
Being physically very active is the mantra to prevent pediatric obesity rather than concentrating efforts at restricting energy consumption.

In one cohort study, involving around 2000 patients, the median overall survival of patients with high BMI was 25.6 months while the low BMI patients showed a median survival of 17.1 months.

The study beginning in 2003, showed that the mortality rate of overweight patients was 16% less during the course of the study.

Body Mass Index
The BMI calculator helps you assess your weight indicating if it is normal or if you are underweight or overweight, based on your height.

The authors of this study, led by senior and corresponding author Toni K. Choueiri, MD, director of the Lank Center for Genitourinary Oncology at Dana-Farber, noted that prior research too has shown that kidney cancer in obese patients showed less aggressive pathological features. They also had better overall survival, even with metastatic disease when treated with targeted therapies.

In the new study, Choueiri and his colleagues, including first author Laurence Albiges, PhD, earlier a visiting scientist at Dana-Farber, presently GU Medical Oncology Lead at Institut Gustave Roussy in France, validated these findings in four separate databases, which Choueiri said "makes this a very strong study."

Test Your Knowledge on Kidney Cancer
Kidney cancer also called renal cancer is one of the top 10 most common cancers in both men and women. Kidney cancer mostly affects people above 65 years of age. There are four types of kidney cancer namely renal cell carcinoma, transitional cell carcinoma, Wilms tumor and renal sarcoma.

Results of the International Metastatic Renal Cell Cancer Database Consortium Study

Data provided from 19 centers of the International Metastatic Renal Cell Carcinoma Database Consortium (IMDC) were analyzed to determine the effect of BMI on patient survival and treatment outcome following first and second line Targeted therapy (TT). The height and weight of patients were also recorded at the start of therapy.

Results showed that treatment with targeted therapy (TT) in overweight or obese patients was independently associated with a better prognosis, even in patients having renal carcinoma that had spread to distant sites.

The researchers also analyzed pooled data on 4657 patients treated for renal cancer in clinical trials conducted between 2003 and 2013 in a validation set.

Molecular Studies of Obese Kidney Cancer Patients

Another database from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) project, included clinical and genomic information on 324 kidney cancer patients. The fourth database contained cancer tissue samples from 146 renal cancer patients who were treated at Dana-Farber and other centers affiliated to Harvard.

Analyzing the above two databases, the investigators looked for molecular level differences between patients having high and low BMI to try and explain why kidney tumors in obese and overweight patients were less aggressive and responded better to therapy.

The TCGA study did not show any differences in the tumors' DNA, such as mutations, that could explain the difference. However, when the scientists studied gene expression - the rate at which genetic information was being used by the cell to make proteins, they noticed a difference. Expression of a gene called fatty acid synthase (FASN) was found to be reduced in patients with high BMI when compared with normal BMI patients.

FASN and Cancer

FASN is a key enzyme involved in lipogenesis or fatty acid synthesis. Overexpression of FASN has been found in many types of cancer, to the extent that it has been nicknamed a ‘metabolic oncogene’.

FASN overexpression has been associated with a poor prognosis in several types of cancer, including kidney cancer.

As FASN expression was decreased or "downregulated" in overweight and obese kidney cancer patients, it would probably explain why these patients did better than those who were of normal weight and showed a higher FASN gene expression.

Possible Therapeutic Role for FASN Inhibitors in Kidney Cancer

The reason for FASN downregulation in obese patients isn't yet known. However the authors of the study say the results provide a valid reason for experiments aimed at inhibiting FASN expression in kidney cancer patients irrespective of their BMI, in an obvious effort to improve the prognosis. Inhibitors of FASN, including some naturally derived products, have been under development for several years and are considered to be an encouraging approach to cancer therapy.

"We plan to test FASN inhibitors in an animal model as a possible therapy for kidney cancer," said Choueiri.

About Kidney (Renal) Cancer

Renal cancer is a malignant growth involving the kidneys. Kidney cancer is the seventh most common cancer in men and tenth most common cancer in women. In 2016, an estimated 62,700 adults (39,650 men and 23,050 women) in the United States will be diagnosed with kidney cancer. There are three main types of kidney cancer.

Renal cell cancer is commonly seenin adults.
Wilms tumors are most commonly seen in children. These two types originate in the renal tubules (tissues of the kidney that form urine).
Transitional cell canceris another type of kidney tumor occurring in adults, that forms in the renal pelvis and ureter.