Netflix Series may Not be Linked to High US Suicide Rates

The Netflix series '13 Reasons Why' may not be associated with high US suicide rates, suggested a new study.

After its release in 2017, '13 Reasons Why' spurred controversy over concerns that its portrayal of a teenage girl's suicide could increase suicide contagion among adolescents.

Overview Suicide
Suicide is an act of ending one's own life and it usually results from emotional isolations and inability to adjust and cope with one's environment.

‘A study found that viewing the second season of "13 Reasons Why" may have had beneficial effects on some young viewers and harmful effects on other viewers.’

Though a much-publicized 2019 study found a contagion effect among boys, a subsequent reanalysis of that data by the Annenberg Public Policy Center (APPC) of the University of Pennsylvania concluded that, to the contrary, the series had no clear effect on teen suicide.

Now, in a pair of commentaries published in the journal PLOS ONE, the original authors challenged the APPC reanalysis and APPC research director Daniel Romer defended his critique.

"We stand by our reanalysis. There is no reason or evidence to suggest that the show had an effect before it was even released," said Romer.

Netflix's '13 Reasons Why' Impact on Young Adults Risk of Suicide: Study
Watching Netflix's 13 Reasons Why series that focuses on suicidal content might have both harmful and helpful effects, finds a new study.

"And as the authors of the study acknowledged, one would expect the show to have a strong effect on female adolescents, which was not found," Romer added.

In their 2019 paper, researchers claimed to find an increase in suicide in 10- to 17-year-old boys over as long as a 10-month period, starting the month before Netflix released the series.

Sales of Essure Birth Control Stopped Prior Netflix Release �The Bleeding Edge�
Manufacturing of Essure, a birth control device is stopped in the U.S before the Netflix documentary release 'The Bleeding Edge.'

But an APPC reanalysis of that data, published early in 2020, failed to detect any reliable increase in suicide in girls and an increase for boys one month before and one month after the release in April 2017.

In their new PLOS commentary, the researchers responded that Netflix "was actively broadcasting advertisements and series' trailers" in March 2017 "that targeted youth and encouraged them to watch this dramatisation of an adolescent girl's suicide."

Suicide Risk Higher Among Sexually Harassed Employees
Suicidal behaviors are increasingly observed among workers facing sexual harassment at the workplace. Targeting the social work environment and behaviors could decrease the burden of suicide.

But Romer found that considerable evidence that the show did not create concerns about contagion until April, citing other independent analyses that focused on April as the point at which Google searches and crisis-line discussions began to rise.

The study found no change in trend the month before the release and a sharp decrease shortly after the release of the series.

"These opposing effects make it difficult to determine whether the potentially harmful effect for some female adolescents was counterbalanced by beneficial effects for others," Romer said.

Source-IANS