Scientists Discover How the Brain Triggers Unplanned Actions

New research reveals how spontaneous movements originate in the brain and explains slow-ramping neural activity before action.

New research sheds light on how spontaneous movements occur without external stimuli and has significant implications for understanding the slow ramping of neural activity observed before movement, a phenomenon that remains largely mysterious. Published in Nature Communications, the study led by Jake Gavenas Ph.D explores how the brain triggers spontaneous actions and deepens our understanding of this process().

Gavenas and his team offer a potential explanation for this process. They simulated spontaneous activity in basic neural networks and compared their simulations to intracortical recordings of humans engaging in spontaneous movement. The findings reveal that rapid fluctuations among individual neurons can interact within a network, leading to much slower fluctuations at the population level.

Specific Region in Human Brain Triggers Inherent Risk-Taking Preferences
The brain scans of study participants showed that they increased their perceived value of a gamble after seeing other people take that gamble.

‘Rapid neuronal fluctuations can lead to slow, spontaneous activity before movements. #neuroscience #medindia ’

Mysterious Onset of Spontaneous Actions: From Decision to Movement

Imagine, for example, standing atop a high-dive platform and trying to summon the willpower to jump. Nothing in the outside world tells you when to jump; that decision comes from within. At some point you experience deciding to jump and then you jump.

In the background, your brain (or, more specifically, your motor cortex) sends electrical signals that cause carefully coordinated muscle contractions across your body, resulting in you running and jumping. But where in the brain do these signals originate, and how do they relate to the conscious experience of willing your body to move?

Starting from the 1960s, neuroscientists have found that electrical activity in the brain ramps up 1-2 seconds before spontaneous voluntary actions. Many scientists thought that the onset of this ramping reflected preparation to move following a preconscious decision to act. But, despite investigations into the origins of this slowly ramping activity, it seemed as though it suddenly emerged “out of nowhere”.

Addiction Relapse Might be Thwarted by Turning Off Brain Trigger: Study
A new study offers encouraging findings that researchers hope may one day lead to a treatment option for people who suffer from alcohol abuse disorders and other addictions.

Debating Free Will and Threshold-Crossing: The Origins of Slow-Ramping Neural Activity

In the years since, neuroscientists and philosophers have debated what this ramping means for free will and conscious self-control: if, following an early decision to move, the brain is preparing to move 2 seconds (or more, according to some studies) before you consciously decide to move, might your actions be largely unconsciously predetermined? Understanding the neural origin of this ramping activity is therefore a paramount problem in neuroscience.

The view that there is preconscious information in the brain seconds before action onset has been challenged by neuroscientists like Maoz and Schurger. In particular, in 2012 Schurger suggested that the slow ramping brain activity is part of a larger process, in which slow background fluctuations in motor-cortex activity must reach a certain threshold to initiate movement.

Low Sugar in Brain Triggers Craving for Junk Food
A new study led by an Indian-origin researcher reveals that our desire for high-calorie food shoots up when there is low sugar in the brain. Feeding the brain with sugar could lower the craving.

If those slow fluctuations help to determine the moment of threshold crossing, then looking back from movement onset ensures that you will observe slow ramping beforehand, even if the ramping is not the outcome of an early preconscious decision to move. In this view, the important event is not the onset of the slow-ramping process but instead the crossing of the threshold.

Although compelling, this explanation leaves a key unanswered question: where do these slow background fluctuations in neural activity, commonly known as 1/f noise, come from in the first place, given that the activity of individual neurons fluctuates quite rapidly?

Cocaine Cravings in Brain Triggered by Nicotine
The first molecular explanation for the gateway sequence of drug abuse has been detailed in a new study.

Gavenas’s study is the first to explain how those slow background fluctuations emerge from networks of neurons, where none of the individual neurons by themselves operate on that long of a time-scale. Those slow fluctuations may then, in turn, contribute to a threshold-crossing event, of the kind that is thought to trigger movement, and thus to the slow ramping that is evident before spontaneous action onset and beyond.

Gavenas said, “we see similar slow-ramping signals before other kinds of spontaneous behaviors, like coming up with creative ideas or freely remembering things that have happened to you. A similar process might therefore underlie those phenomena, but only time and further research will tell.”

In sum, this is a landmark study because it offers a potential explanation for the origin of slow, spontaneous fluctuations in population-level neural activity, which is a ubiquitous phenomenon in neural systems. In addition, according to Maoz, “It reveals the bias we have as researchers to think that our results uncover a causal mechanism, when it may really be just a correlation.”

Reference:

Slow ramping emerges from spontaneous fluctuations in spiking neural networks - (https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-51401-x)

Source-Eurekalert